Logo

How’s your Sister?

When the two-part investigation into U.S. women religious was announced in early 2009, reaction varied from "How dare they" to "It's about time." Many Catholics, however, were simply shocked and confused. What do you think about the investigations and the lives of women religious today? Tell us in this Reader Survey. We will publish the result in the January 2010 issue of U.S. Catholic.

Are you a woman religious? Please take our survey "Go ask Sister." We want to find out what your lives are like-straight from you. (It is similar to this survey, with a few additional specific questions.)

Know women religious? Please circulate our survey of them, "Go ask Sister," so that we can get a wide-ranging response. Thank you!

Survey deadline: Nov. 1, 2009

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

We are long overdue for

We are long overdue for recognition and appreciation as the leaders of the church we have always been.

Information Please!!!

Many of the previous comments reveal a serious lack of knowledge of the history of religious orders for women and how they evolved from orders of monks even before the time of Christ, the monastic orders such as Benedictines, orders formed by saints like St. Vincent de Paul to work among the poor and who dressed like the peasants of the day,and the changes called for by Pius XII and Vatican II. All this led to most of the changes we see today. For an excellent essay covering this history and the theology, especially biblical, upon which it is based, may I refer you to the following URL.
http://ncronline.org/news/discerning-ministerial-religious-life-today
It will help to make intelligent assessments rather than uninformed judgments.

Thanks

Thanks

Investigations are constructive

An investigation is not a punishment; it is meant to assist. It is impossible to deny that women religious are in a crisis. The numbers of nuns are dropping steadily in the United States. Why, then, it is so surprising that the Vatican is sending them assistance? I work at a Catholic school, that is currently going through its reaccreditation process. In the course of this process, the directors of the school have done an "investigation" of their own: sending out surveys, getting feedback, and enlisting outside assistance to help strengthen the areas that the school could improve. No one saw this as unfair; it is just and healthy for the hierarchy of an institution to examine different branches occasionally. Furthermore, it can be very helpful to strengthen and improve areas of weakness.
The fact that a normal procedure has raised such outcry amongst nuns is suspicious. Why are they not eager to have help in remedying a problem--dwindling nuns and sisters--that is affecting the entire Church? Is this not the essence of pride and injustice?
As for claims that this investigation is sexist, I would like to remind everyone that the Vatican undertook a formal investigation of all seminaries in the United States a few years ago. The men were checked out first. Why are sisters pretending that they are being singled out? The Vatican even put a sister in charge of this investigation. These are not the actions of an anti-woman organization.

Accrediting a school is

Accrediting a school is certainly not the same as an investigation into one's life.
Divorces are at an all time high. Why not investigate a Catholic marriage?
Seminaries were investigated only because the bishops screwed up on the sex abuse crisis. Why not investigate the bishops and ask why they still do not apologize or take responsibility for what they did. The number of priests is also dwindling: why no investigation? Or are the last 2 issues just the usual "boys will be boys?".

nuns investigation

This is a bogus investigation of the ONLY area within the church that is responsive to social needs.
The heirarchy is still ignoring the absolute hypocrisy of the institution.
Approximately 1/2 of the priests are homosexual.
And 1/2 of them are sexually active AND half of the heteroralsexual priests are also sexually active. This is from the church's own records.
There still is no real transparency to the abuse crisis and diocese after diocese is dragged through court and billions are spent of the laity money since ALL money is from the laity.
Watch what happens in the Bridgeport diocese as 14000 pages of previously secret personnel files are made public and we find out what "they" knew and what they did.

Unfair Judgement

All of these comments make me very angry. Who are you people to be passing judgement on women who have chosen a lifestyle and have ministered all their lives for the good of others? Would you like someone deciding that since you are married you should wear only one style of dress? Or because you are single you need to cover your face with a veil? If you have never lived the life of a nun, then you are not qualified to pass judgement on their work, their lifestyle, their dress. Look to your own houses, your own life!

Suspicion

I think most suspicion comes out of fear and fear comes from past experience. In the past, women have experienced repression and subjugation so much when attention is focused on us, that we fear that as a common result.

I think it's good to be alert, but also cooperative, and to live in hope that this "inventory" may lead to positive change -- at the very least open more dialog that can be built upon. I'm not naieve enough to think it's the answer to the frustrations of our search for equality, but any step forward is at least not a step backward.

Until we know differently, I'd like to assign at least ambivilent motives, but at the most positive, prayerful and forward-thinking theological motives to this effort.

"I'm not naive enough to

"I'm not naive enough to think it's the answer to the frustrations of our search for equality"

What sort of equality are you searching for?

Sister ain't the problem

I wish the Vatican had put this much assessment effort into the Church sex abuse scandal

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Comments are limited to a maximum of 1500 characters.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Filtered words will be replaced with the filtered version of the word.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Answer this question to prove you are a human visitor and prevent automated spam submissions.