Practicing (not just) Catholic
A Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life poll found that six in 10 Americans blend practices and beliefs from a variety of traditions, including New Age spirituality.
That's the highlight reported by ABC News. While it's significant that a quarter of Americans (and Catholics) hold Eastern or New Age beliefs, the people highlighted by ABC--who have really blended their faiths--aren't exactly representative.
Nineteen percent of Catholics attend services in different faiths (other than for special occasions), significantly less than the total population. The people most committed to going to church (at least once a week) are less likely to stray from their home church than those who attend monthly or annually. Finally, when both Protestants and Catholics say they attend a service of another faith, they most often mean they attended a Protestant service.
This study reminds me of Huston Smith's autobiography, Tales of Wonder. Smith brought The World's Religions to Americans in his book by that name. His publishers have pushed the book as "a story of uncanny synchronicity," seeing as Smith has been at so many important events and met so many important people in his 90 years.
But what most fascinated me about Smith was the way he learned about other religions. This son of a Methodist missionary practiced Buddhism, Islam, and Hinduism for 10 years each without giving up his own faith and practice as a Christian. He went far beyond the dialogue of interfaith relations to experience the "other."
The ABC story had me thinking that Americans were beyond interfaith dialogue, but a closer look at the numbers reveals that we have a long way to go before achieving such understanding across religions. I doubt those who visit other churches study the actual beliefs and practices as carefully as Smith did.
As with Smith and Karen Armstrong, my own study and experience of other faiths has brought be back to my own.
How about you? Have you visited the services of other faiths? Has family led you to celebrating Christmas at a Protestant church? When you're there, do you feel that you're worshiping the same God or do you feel that someting is lacking (or perhaps both)?
Do you study other faiths outside of Christianity? Have eastern traditions such as yoga or new age spirituality been incorporated into your own faith life?
Quakers
By Megan Sweas on Monday, January 4, 2010Take a look at this post on Loyola Press about Beliefnet's Belief-O-Matic test. Paul says all the Catholics he knew ended up something other than Catholic, with Quaker being extremely popular (Quaker was high for me too, but I actually don't know much about their specific beliefs, so I can't tell you why).
Oh! come on. It is
By Anonymous (not verified) on Sunday, December 27, 2009Oh! come on. It is impossible to practice severals different faiths at once and be true to one's own religion. One cannot be a practicing Islamist and a practicing orthodox Catholic at the same time. One cannot be a faithful Lutheran and a faithful Catholic at the same time. It just means that the person is not really a Catholic or or a lutheran or Islamist but just making up his/her own religion. They are really lukewarm and belong to nothing. They either do not believe the Catholic religion is the true faith or that there is a true one. It is all right to co-operate with other religions where there is common ground, but to try to be more than one at the same time is ludicrous. Remember those who could not keep "the hard sayings" left the Lord Jesus because they were "summertime" followers. When the going got tough, the weak or uncommitted left or leave.
Friends
By Tom (not verified) on Thursday, December 24, 2009I was raised a Catholic, spent 2 years in a seminary and worked for the church. I left the church and spent 12 years as a Quaker and don't regret one moment of it. I am now back in the Catholic Church. Leaving was important to find what was there all along. I take with me my quakerism and am a better Catholic because of it.
The Quakers
By David Phillips (not verified) on Thursday, December 24, 2009Although I would certainly never encourage anyone to leave the Roman Catholic Church for the Society of Friends, I do admire the fact that throughout history, the Quakers have often worked for peace, for social progress, and for kindess and love. They have also been leaders in that they often have readily admitted the flaws and faults in their own history.
A great book written by two members of Friends is "Beyond Prisons: A New Interfaith Paradigm for our Failed Prison System."
The Quakers pushed society forward back in the 1700's by founding jails and penitentiaries (beyond forms of punishment like whippings, various tortures, executions, etc). Today, they are pushing society to move beyond the prison to new forms of restorative justice.
Practicing (Not Just) Catholic
By Anonymous (not verified) on Wednesday, December 23, 2009I have studied the Religious Society of Friends. I m not a member, but for the past five months I have attended a Friends Meeting every week. It is truly the faith of "perhaps" -- recognizing there are many paths to God. The simplicity, quiet, direct relationship with God, the lack of judgement by others, respect for other faith traditions, the belief God is in every one, the expectation that we are all "clergy" as well as that no day is religiously more special than the next, has brought more meaning to my daily life. Many of these points can be found in Catholicism, but, for me, seem to be buried in ritual and man. As a Quaker or attender, the religious experience is based on your preparation and patience. There is no priest to say Mass or a sermon to critique. I did start attending Meeting because there was something missing in my spiritual life and I wanted to experience something completely different. I am not a Catholic basher. I do attend Mass with my wife and children. Will I return to Catholicism or stay in the quiet and the uncluttered--I don't know. What I do know is that there are wonderful and important traditions in each faith that draw us closer to God. For me and others, the key is to find the best path to God or the Divine and support others on their journey.
Friends
By Bryan Cones on Wednesday, December 23, 2009I like the Friends myself--never attended a meeting, but I'm amazed at how the Quakers have so often been trailblazers on things like the abolition of slavery and the search for peace. Perhaps because they focus so much on listening to God rather than talking about God all the time...
Bryan Cones


