US bishops say new John Jay report on abuse key to understanding issue
WASHINGTON (CNS) -- U.S. Catholic bishops called the newly released report on the causes and context of clergy sexual abuse an important tool to gain insight into the scope of the problem and prevent it from occurring in the future.
"It is important for us to understand, as completely and accurately as we are able, the causes and context of this problem in order to respond appropriately for the safety and protection of our children and young people," wrote St. Louis Archbishop Robert J. Carlson in an editorial for the St. Louis Review, archdiocesan newspaper.
The report: "The Causes and Context of Sexual Abuse of Minors by Catholic Priests in the United States, 1950-2010," was released May 18. It was conducted by a team of researchers at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice of the City University of New York and commissioned by the National Review Board, a lay consultative body created in 2002 under the bishops' "Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People."
An earlier study on the nature and scope of abuse appeared in February 2004. The causes and context study commenced in 2006.
Detroit Archbishop Allen H. Vigneron called the comprehensive report "both sobering and significant," saying in a May 18 statement that it was "yet another indicator to keep us vigilant in our efforts for the protection of children and youth."
New York Archbishop Timothy M. Dolan, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, said the report pointed out "that there was no single cause that led to the sexual abuse crisis. Neither celibacy, as some have suggested, nor homosexuality, as others have claimed, has been found to be a reason why a person would engage in sexual abuse of a minor."
He also said in a statement that the study "is a report to the bishops of the United States, not from them," noting that initial reaction to it was critical of U.S. bishops.
Members of Catholic groups unhappy with the study protested outside USCCB headquarters immediately before the document's release. Participants from Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP, Voice of the Faithful and bishopsaccountability.org, described the study as flawed, biased and not addressing the scope of the abuse crisis.
A handful of protesters carried signs reading: "Not True: Crisis Is Not Foreseeable" and "Not True: Crisis Was Long Ago."
Becky Ianni, director of SNAP in Washington and Virginia, told Catholic News Service she would like to see a study of bishops who moved abusive priests to other locations more than a study of abusive priests. Ianni, who was abused by a priest when she was a child, also said it minimizes her suffering to hear that the abuse she experienced was a "product of the time period," referring to the report's link of clerical abuse to the social upheaval of the 1960s and 1970s.
The report showed that sexual abuse of minors by priests "increased steadily from the mid-1960s through the late 1970s, then declined in the 1980s and continues to remain low. Most abuse incidents occurred decades ago."
Baltimore Archbishop Edwin F. O'Brien said that the report's link of increase number of abuse cases during a socially turbulent time period should not provide consolation.
"While it may be comforting for some to learn that there is nothing intrinsic in our church or its makeup that contributes to the presence of sexual abuse, it does not mitigate the damaging effects of sexual abuse that did occur in our church," he said in a column for The Catholic Review, the archdiocesan newspaper.
He also noted that although the abuse crisis is "a historical problem," it has "not been completely eradicated from our church or from our society. We have the responsibility to protect children entrusted to our care and we must be ever vigilant in our efforts to prevent any incident of sexual abuse."
Archbishop Dolan pointed out that the sexual abuse of minors affects every family, religion, school, organization, institution and profession in society and credited the U.S. Catholic Church for being "the first group anywhere to contract a professional agency" to examine the "causes and contexts of this scourge." He also said the study closely mirrors what has taken place in the New York Archdiocese, specifically that the vast majority of sexual abuse occurred decades ago and has declined sharply in the Catholic Church since 1985.
Archbishop Carlson apologized to those who had been abused by church officials and assured them of the church's "unshakeable commitment to protect our children" and make church facilities and programs safe environments for minors. He also urged anyone who had been abused by a church official to contact the archdiocese. Archbishop Dolan similarly apologized to abuse victims in his statement.
The archbishops praised local efforts of archdiocesan programs in place to implement the charter and provide safe environments for young people today, emphasizing such steps are key to preventing further abuse.
"After the painful revelations of the sexual abuse crisis, the only greater sin our church could commit would be a failure to follow the very policies and procedures we have in place to protect children and root out abusers. And that can never happen," said Archbishop O'Brien.
Copyright © 2011 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops
We don't need a study to
By Don R (not verified) on Thursday, May 19, 2011We don't need a study to confirm what we already know. The bishops covered up crimes so there would be no scandals. They acted just like corporate executives in covering their behinds and preserving their corporate image. If they can get away with it in the future, they will do the same thing, since they are accountable to nobody but themselves.
I don't care how many studies are commissioned or how many task forces are started, unless there is some consequences for their actions nothing will change.
Surprised?
By Jim (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011Yes, many (not all) Bishops did attempt to cover it up. Yes they did it to a kid scandal. What surprises me is your selection for an analogy. Why not say, "the Bishops covered it up just like many mothers who know child abuse exits is their home."? Why not say, "the bishops covered it up just like many schools and hospitals who have transferred these offenders without any warning to the new community so they could avoid scandal and pass their problem on to someone else."?
In other words Don, they did what one would expect when confronted with a scandal, they tried to avoid it. That stategy failed. However, unlike many homes, schools, hospitals, etc the Church set about the business of righting the wrong. Now we have one of the safest institutional environments in this country for children.
This country has a lot if soul searching to do with regards to child abuse. Fortunately the Church will be in a humble position to teach others from the errors of the small number of offenders who harmed and wounded so many. Be part of the solution, not the problem as we move forward to uproot child a use in every dark corner.
Latest Scandal in KC
By Don R (not verified) on Monday, May 23, 2011See the latest scandal involving Bishop Finn. http://www.kctv5.com/news/27969089/detail.html
Quote from the bishop: "I deeply regret that we didn’t ask the police earlier to conduct a full investigation."
If nothing changes, nothing changes. Possession of child pornography is a crimal offense! In spite of all of the revelations over the past years, this stuff is still going on. Some of the bishops still don't get it. Until they are fired and arrested this stuff will continue.
I agree that there are
By Don R (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011I agree that there are pedaphiles in all walks of life, and many of these cases are unreported and covered up too. They are just as wrong as the bishops who covered up the problems.
As regards to safest institutional environments in the country I hope you are right. Incidents will continue to occur in the church even in the current environment. How the bishops handle them in the future reamins to be seen.
Agreed. Although I have not
By Jim (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011Agreed. Although I have not yet seen the numbers for 2010, I can tell you that there were 6 credible accusations made against Catholic clergy in 2009. Now, many SNAP members have tried to hold other religious institutions as accountable as the Catholic Church. Check out stopbaptistpredators.org to see how having bishops, even bad ones, helps track and hold accountable an institution that is unified. Additionally, I remember SNAP having nothing but good things to say about Pope Benedict when he visited with survivors in New York. Just adding some overall perspective to a situation which you rightly recognize as a "time will tell" situation. All things being equal, I think the Church has done more than any other institution to incorporate safety measures for the children in her care. Think about it. The scandal broke around 2000. In about ten years the Church has done studies, accepted lay oversight comities, invited the FBI to place an envoy to the Vatican and replaced numerous bishops. Sure, not everyone is happy but when have we ever been able to please everyone?
Well said, Jim. I wish
By Anonymous (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011Well said, Jim. I wish others, in particular the media and ex-Catholics, would take your comments to heart and to prayer.
...we can only hope, as the
By Jim (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011...we can only hope, as the stales are our very own children!!! God bless all men and women of goodwill.
Finally, someone said it
By Anonymous (not verified) on Friday, May 20, 2011Finally, someone said it succinctly. I agree with you, Don.
So, now that we know the problem, what is the solution? What can be done to prevent it from happening again?
I think that the steps and
By Anonymous (not verified) on Saturday, May 21, 2011I think that the steps and measures are in place, at least at the parish and victim level. At that level, in most diocese, there are required in services and programs for volunteers, school and parish employees, and children designed specifically to educate these people in handling cases and potential cases. These programs could go parish-wide, being offered to all parishioners, including parents.
I am not aware of programs at the clergy level because I am not clergy. My lack of awareness does no mean there is none. I repeat: my lack of awareness does not mean there is none. Please do not presume that because I am not aware of them that there is none.
Way to go
By Jim (not verified) on Thursday, May 19, 2011Thumbs up to the Catholic Church for creating the safest institutional environment for children anywhere in the United States. It was hard work and justly humiliating but I am grateful to the Bishops, Priests and Laity for their perseverance and hard work. Great job!!!
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.

