Papal prescription for universal health care
The pope’s stance on health care may be hard pill to swallow for opponents of reform.
More than 100 million people a year across the world are driven into poverty because of the cost of illness or “catastrophic injury,” the United Nations reported in November. Whether in the affluent or the developing world, nations that rely on individual resources to sustain health care systems (rather than pooled government resources) produced the highest amount of health-related impoverishment among their citizens.
World Health Organization officials, arguing that the need “has never been greater” because of the worldwide economic slowdown, globalization of disease, and an aging world population that will need more care for chronic conditions, are calling for an international campaign for universal health care.
As a nation, the United States remains far from the goal of universal coverage. But the recent health care reform effort, derided as “Obamacare” by its many detractors, at least steps toward treating health care as a human right rather than a commodity. Although it will be years before U.S. health care reform takes complete shape, assuming it survives the congressional and judicial challenges ahead, one component of reform is already protecting Americans and addressing one of WHO’s major preoccupations.
In the United States the main cause of personal bankruptcy has been the overwhelming medical costs of a major health crisis, even for people who thought they had “good” health insurance. Beginning last September, the reform package initiated restrictions on the annual limits insurers can place on their plans, and those limits will be phased out completely by 2014. Also in September the practice of searching for technical errors in applications in order to deny the sick or injured insurance precisely when they need it most was outlawed. Together these two small steps will prevent thousands of American families from facing ruin because of a medical crisis.
Health reform has proved a rallying point for many opposed to the Obama administration’s actual or purported initiatives, although when reform’s specific goals and progress points are diagrammed, many “opponents” end up supporting the reform’s milestones.
“Obamacare” has proved a useful organizational tool for the Tea Party, which has drawn the support of a good number of Catholics. I offer a kindly warning to Tea Party hosts so eager to receive Catholic RSVPs: Guess who else is coming to dinner? Pope Benedict XVI, carrying a delectable platter of more than 100 years of Catholic social teaching.
In fact Pope Benedict joined WHO’s call for universal health coverage just before its report hit the press. He called health care a moral responsibility of government and an “inalienable right,” regardless of social and economic status or ability to pay. He cautioned that the privatization of health care should “not become a threat to the accessibility, availability, and quality of health care.”
Pope Benedict also recently called for “renewed evangelization of the church’s social doctrine,” reminding laypeople that they have “the immediate task of working for a just social order.” One concept of that social doctrine, subsidiarity, has been twisted into odd shapes lately in an effort to get it to conform to our dominant culture’s more ruggedly individualistic impulses. But subsidiarity relates more to preventing government from thwarting individual expression in addressing civic concerns; it does not, as some suggest, absolve government from a responsibility to respond to pressing social needs.
Catholics helped codify the recently derided ideals of “social justice.” We embrace our communal and personal responsibilities; the sojourner and orphan are not objects of our charity but brothers and sisters we seek to stand with and hold up, not just help out. Subsidiarity will have a defining role to play—along with other Catholic notions such as the common good, human dignity, and the preferential option for the poor—as we work through whatever form our health care system finally takes.
Let’s hope that when our Catholic brethren play musical seats at the Tea Party, they will leave a place for our pope’s recent exhortations and the rich tradition of social justice that has been the lifebreath of our holy, imperfect communion.
Kevin Clarke is a writer living in New York. This article appeared in the February 2011 issue of U.S. Catholic (Vol. 76, No. 2, page 39.
I'm glad to see our Pope
By Anonymous (not verified) on Tuesday, April 19, 2011I'm glad to see our Pope weigh in on these matters. However, he is going to have to become a lot louder in these things to drown out Sarah Palin and other tea partiers. Let's see our local dioceses get this out to the parishes and renew the social justice.
healthcare
By Anonymous (not verified) on Friday, February 4, 2011I have been told that at the end of this year I will be losing my job because my company can no longer aford my health care coverage which is expected to rise dut to obamacare. The loss of jobs is what is causing poverty in this country, not lack of access to healthcare. The government is not concerned about saving money regarding healthcare, if they were, they would encourage competition by allowing people from one state to buy insurance in another state. Their objective is to take over our lives, a good way to impose population control. When rationing starts, and it will, it will still be the poor, the elderly and the young who will be put out to pasture by this government. To think otherwise is absolutely naive. Look what is happening in England, people are dying daily because the government cannot give them the healthcare they need due to the expense, hence, rationing. Their hospitals are filthy, they are understaffed and overworked. This is the future of healthcare in america if obamacare is allowed to stand as is.
Dr. H. and Patricia's
By Jane (not verified) on Wednesday, February 2, 2011Dr. H. and Patricia's comments are related, it appears. The vocation of being a medical practitioner appears to often be overlooked for its financial rewards. That being said, I understand that it's a complex mess, starting with the cost of malpractice insurance, followed by the high cost of medical machinery in the U.S. ( from what I've read, this is not the case in other industrialized countries). The common denominator in this problem, as in so many in our country now, is greed. As previously stated, I'm happy to have some common ground with our Pope on this one issue, at least.
Greed
By Jerry D (not verified) on Wednesday, February 2, 2011"The common denominator in this problem, as in so many in our country now, is greed."
Are you suggesting we set up a system where we demand from each according to abilities; to each according to his needs? Why do you see greed is a problem of our country? Are the people of America more greedy than those of other countries?
In utopia, people will work their tails off to get throught medical school and continue to work hard to develop the medical miracles and in return for pay of what you determine is "fair."
Crowning your politics with a papal tiara
By Anonymous (not verified) on Tuesday, February 1, 2011More government is not the answer. Just look at their record on financial issues. Medicare is a mess: do you really think that government will responsibly administer a much larger program? Waste, fraud and abuse is rampant now and under Obamacare would be pandemic.
Call Obamacare what you will, on a political spectrum, it falls far left in the realm of socialism. That's not a slur, it's an observation.
Then you warn us that your big brother the Pope is coming?! Better watch out or I'll sic the Pope on you?! He's coming to dinner and he's bringing a big plate of crow?!
1. Grow up. 2. Your Roman Triumphalist Arrogance should be stored it in a warm, wet place. 3. Stop writing provocations and give reason a try.
Start by explaining how it will be paid for, followed by how it's moral to force someone to buy a product
Profit
By Jim L. (not verified) on Tuesday, February 1, 2011Profit is not always helpful, as Dr. Hedequist reminds us. Not in medicine, or many other services. Look what it has done to the micro-loan progam in India. The loansharks have ruined what works so well in Bangladesh. Look what it did on Wall Street and all the havoc it wreaked on Main Street. Putting reasonable, humane limits on profiteering is not socialism. And socialism is not a sin. Profiteering is. And profit making can all too easily morph into profiteering, hence the many biblical injunctions against pursuit of wealth without regard for how this pursuit affects others.
Those who equate Obama and
By Cocat (not verified) on Tuesday, February 1, 2011Those who equate Obama and health insurance reform with socialism (or worse) just don't get it. They're trapped in a mindset that glorifies individual "freedom" at the expense of anyone who makes less money or has the misfortune of losing their job or getting sick. I thank God that Obama and the courageous in Congress who passed healh insurance reform have made this small start toward human justice. And if it costs me a little money or some imagined "freedom" to help save human lives, then that's a price I'm willing to pay. Are you?
Universal Health Care
By Maureen (not verified) on Tuesday, February 1, 2011As one of the many who have been denied health insurance due to a pre-existing condition, I have welcomed the changes that are being brought to bear by the health care reform bill. Does it go far enough? No. But it hangs together as a whole, and you can't eliminate the mandeate for everyone to carry health insurance and make the rest of it work. All must be covered to share the burden of health care costs.
But along with the social responsibilities outlined by the Church in this regard, let us remember that we each have an individual responsiblity to take care of our own health, in respect for the life we are given by God. And many, many more people are not doing that, which raises costs for everyone. That is what is not fair. Our responsiblity to ourselves hangs with our responsibility to the whole, and both need to be addressed for universal health care to work.
It's time for me to go out for my walk. How about you?
Social justice
By Jim90069 (not verified) on Tuesday, February 1, 2011It's nice to see the Catholic Church come out again, and fulfilling it's role as teacher. It's about time.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.

