Logo

The lies are killing us: The need for immigration reform

Monday, October 25, 2010
The lies are killing us: The need for immigration reform
Karl W. Hoffman skullcreekmedia.com
ShareThis
Understanding that “you are my other self” will lead us to a new national vision grounded in solidarity. This is the Latino good news, says a priest from the border.

I come from the El Paso-Juárez border communities. For the past 15 years, El Paso has been ranked as the second safest city in the nation, while, just across the border, Ciudad Juárez ranks the second most dangerous city in the world. Daily in Juárez eight to 10 people are murdered, decapitated, kidnapped, tortured, or are simply disappeared.

Each year between 80,000 and 100,000 children are caught by the border patrol trying to cross illegally into the United States. In our parish we have a ministry with these children, children like 5-year-old Marisol, a beautiful little girl from Guatemala. She was caught trying to cross the border with a coyote, who had been paid to bring her to the United States.

When she was caught, she had a piece of paper in her hand with a phone number in her Guatemalan village. During the whole trip she had kept it in her hand, but when the officers opened it, most of the numbers were missing. This little girl will perhaps forever be separated from her family.

Immigrants like Marisol show us that immigration reform is more than simply a matter of human rights for undocumented immigrants. It is a matter of survival for the poorest. No child of God should ever have to leave her family at 5 years of age to be able to eat and survive in our world. Like the majority of people who cross the border, these are not terrorists or drug smugglers but our brothers and sisters.

The growing anti-immigrant sentiment in our country since 9/11 did not happen because people suddenly wanted to become cruel and heartless. It began because people started believing a lie about who we Latinos are, both documented and undocumented.

This is why immigration is a defining issue that is about us—all of us Latinos—and about how we will shape the future of our church and our country. There is a saying in Spanish, "La mentira nos trae la muerte." Lies bring death.

The lie is that immigrants, and by association all of us Latinos, are disposable as human beings and not worthy of human dignity and respect. And this lie is killing us.

An immigrant recently told me, "I've been sacrificing myself for my family, but in this country I am worth nothing." Latinos and immigrants encounter racism, resentment, and extreme hostilities against them, and they masquerade as patriotism and now also as national security.

By now we are familiar with the countless problems immigrants endure as a result of this lie: an increase in border deaths to more than 400 a year; raids, arrests, and deportations separating families; a backlog in family reunification and visa requests; militarization of the border; sexual exploitation of women immigrants traveling north; abuses in detention centers.

Arizona has recently made national headlines for passing harsh anti-immigrant laws, but today more than 20 states have introduced even harsher laws than Arizona. The solutions these laws propose perpetuate lies, persecute innocent people, expose all of us Latinos to racial profiling, and cause death and suffering to the poor. Those who say that they are not against immigrants yet support such oppressive laws are practicing backdoor racism at its worst.

Sure, every nation has a right to protect its borders against impending threats, but immigrants working to feed their children are not a threat to anyone. Their presence is not a threat, it is a human right; and we support their right to a better life.

Many today scapegoat the poor for self-serving political gain, for economic greed, and security fears. Their lies blind people from seeing Christ in others and keep them from hearing the gospel call to hospitality of the stranger among us. These lies are being used to justify injustice and foster racism that causes pervasive exploitation of immigrants, who are demonized as illegal, as alien, as suspicious human beings.

Since the majority of the more than 90 nationalities that daily cross our borders are from the Americas, it is our Latinidad itself that is being attacked. We know that the root causes of immigration include extreme poverty, unemployment, political and military corruption, and government instability in the countries of origin. However, we Latinos and Latinas throughout the Americas also know that the United States shares in the responsibility for these conditions that drive immigrants north across our borders.

It is not a secret that once the estimated 12 to 20 million currently undocumented immigrants become citizens, our country will be different. This process has already begun, but wait until we get to vote, buy homes, graduate from universities, and become elected officials.

Es mentira, it is a lie that immigrants will not learn English. In our parish we have some 100 people learning English to become citizens, and similar programs exist all over.

Es mentira that all immigrants are here illegally. The truth is that the majority are here on some type of visa.

Es mentira that stronger enforcement along the U.S.-Mexico border will stop immigrants from crossing the border. It is jobs that bring immigrants to the United States.

Es mentira that immigrants are draining our health care and educational systems. The fact is that immigrants contribute about $90 billion in taxes, much more than the $5 billion they use in services.

Msgr. Arturo Bañuelas is the pastor of St. Pius X Parish in El Paso, Texas. This article appeared in the December issue of U.S. Catholic (Vol. 75, No. 12, pages 34-36).

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Another View

Msgr. Banuelas began his article by speaking of Marisol, a little girl who was brought to the border, by a “coyote.” He failed to explain that a “coyote” is a person who transports illegal aliens at prices that are exorbitant and that “coyotes” pack illegal immigrants into closed trucks or trailers for days on end without food or water. Countless documented cases exist in which illegal immigrants have died en route to the United States due to the greediness of the “coyotes.” Often women and children are sold into the sex slave trade, and men are promised jobs that do not exist. Hundreds of immigrants are dying because they are being exploited by those who are willing to bring them to America illegally. America must enforce her immigration laws in order to protect innocent people and to prosecute criminals.

Marisol is a brave little American. I claim her as my own.

What Salris tries to hide is that the only reason coyotes exist, and the only reason immigrants are dying, is because current US immigration laws are unjust, unfair, unworkable, and counterproductive to the point of immorality.

A system of arcane discriminatory quotas ensure that most would-be immigrants are not allowed. Of those who are allowed, only 5,000 unskilled laborers are allowed per year, in spite of the fact that American businesses are willing to hire anywhere from 100,000 to 500,000 MORE laborers per year than can be provided by our own country. Similarly stupid quotas discriminate against Mexicans, Philipinos, Latin Americans, and Catholics in particular. These quotas were written in 1986, and to pretend that they in any way reflect the economic reality or rational self-interests of modern America is a big, fat, lie.

America must pass immigration laws that are workable and just in order to protect innocent people, promote the general welfare, and keep our economy expanding.

TEAR DOWN THAT WALL!

Liberal Thought

Sorry, but your post is pointless to liberals. There answer is there would be no coyotes if we had no border enforcement. They'd had out governemnt funded airplane tickets to anyone who wanted them and sign them up for immediate government assistance if they had their choice.

Thank you!

A most articulate expression of the Gospel read through the eyes of the immigrant. Reminds me of Eduardo Galeano's majestic piece that can be found here:
http://www.patriagrande.net/uruguay/eduardo.galeano/nosotros/nosotros.htm

What about Americans?

How is a Christian supposed to respond to the concerns of Americans who lose jobs to illegal aliens? Shrug them off as selfish? Ignore them? It's easy to give away others' job security and futures. Churches don't pay taxes yet want to run America, the lack of fiscal responsibility shows in their lack of concern for the costs of illegal immigration. I suspect the Church prefers the influx of poor peasants who wil depend on the Church and not question its authority.

Nobody loses their job to an

Nobody loses their job to an immigrant. People get fired because they don't perform, not because someone else comes along "steals" the job.

The fact is that unauthorized immigrants add $17.7 Billion to the state GDP of Texas alone, creating thousands of jobs that wouldn't otherwise exist for US citizens. And they pay in a NET of $147 million in taxes OVER AND ABOVE the value of government services they receive in return. Who's my source? The Office of Comptroller of the State of Texas, led a duly elected conservative Republican.

The lack of fiscal responsiblity you decry is the fault of us citizens and the politicians we elect. You say "what about Americans" as though Americans are somehow being oppressed by some more powerful nation, but what you really mean is that you want someone else to blame for all your own failings.

Urban Legends

Please do some basic research before you pose misguided, to be kind, comments.

For a good while it has been solidly shown that immigrants do not (1) steal or take jobs from citizens, (2) overburden health services, (3) fail to pay taxes (in fact, the IRS is on record that the undocumented who rely on numbered returns probably keep social security afloat). Why don't I link?

Because if you do your own research, there is more of a probability you will change your mind. That is, if your comments are not motivated by open or hidden racism.

Shame on You...

... for making such ignorant hateful charges against the American people: that they are fearful, ignorant and demonizing Latinos.

You're the one doing the demonization. Americans welcome legal immigrants and work, live and welcome into their families Latinos. Sensible people who know that it is prudent to have immigration controls, are then smeared with your hateful charges.

Speaking of shame...

Right back atcha.

The American people are not fearful, ignorant demonizers of Latinos.

Then there are those who pretend that American immigration laws are "prudent", that immigrants are "stealing" jobs (while simultaneously living off welfare), that immigrants have no legal right to exist, and that the mere act of taking a breath is a crime.

Some people accuse anyone who disagrees with them of blaming "the American people", only because they want to use "the American people" as a shield for their own bigotry. Sort of like when terrorists fire mortars indiscriminately at civilians, the terrorists will hide behind other civilians, to use them as a shield.

If USSR invaded Vatican City?.. Would John Paul or Ben welcome..

Msgr. Arturo Banuelas, "New National Vision?" This sounds like a "Race Revolt" to me?...
It's not the same Vision of US citizens who want laws enforced! From Prop-8 to SB-1070!!!!

I would like to encurage Msgr. to give his worldly goods, house his Church etc. To US citizens to do with what they choose...

Also if Msgr. has any retirment money, he can give it to US taxpayers because it's the US taxpayer who pays for many things for the illegal alien. I don't see Benedict XVI giving the Vatican to the USA, for payment for illegal immigrants who cost the US billions yearly!!

The Swiss Govnment deports people who commit crimes!! Why doesn't the Roman Catholic Church send the Swiss Guard home?... It's like the pot calling the kettle black!!! Blame the USA, blame the USA!!! If I knew how the Church would treat me, now. I would have been ok with Presient Regan, letting the Commies invade Europe. Maby if the USSR, took control of Vatican City and there was no God or USA to save the Holy See. You Pro-Illegal Immigration Advicates wouldn't be so snotty!!

If the USSR invaded Vatican City illegallly would John Paul or Benedict XVI welcome the Reds as citizens? Would they cease to be a Pope and hand their job over to people who don't beleave in God?... Where the "State" is the God?...Who knows...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.