Logo

The church's "married clergy": 40 years of Deacons

Monday, October 25, 2010
The church's
Brothers and deacons Aldolfo and Efrain Lopez pray during Mass at St. Genevieve Parish in Chicago. (Karen Callaway/Catholic New World)
ShareThis

 

 

The modern deacon has been around for 40 years—and some are still finding their place in the parish.

Beverly Hills, California deacon and author Eric Stoltz often finds himself uttering the phrase, "Please don't call me Father."

Besides that gentle correction to well-meaning parishioners, Stoltz also uses the first five minutes of new baptism classes he leads to explain to his captive audience what a permanent deacon like himself does.

It's not just Stoltz's parish that could use more education on the diaconate. As the number of permanent deacons continues to rise across the United States, more Catholics are asking, "What exactly does a deacon do?"

Some Catholics think deacons can hear confessions, anoint the sick, and preside at Mass if a priest is unavailable, acting as kind of a substitute priest-all false. Others wonder why a man would choose to be a permanent deacon rather than a priest. Well, for one thing, a deacon can be married.

But some deacons—about 2 percent—are not married, and Stoltz is one of them. "I've had people tell me, ‘Well, you're not married so why don't you just go all the way?' And I say, ‘Oh, you mean bishop?' " he laughs. "I explain to them that I don't have the vocation to be a priest."

But why be a deacon? Joseph M. Donadieu of the Diocese of Trenton, New Jersey, who was already involved and active in his parish, faced that question. When Msgr. James P. McManimon, who started the permanent diaconate program in Trenton, asked him to consider the ministry, Donadieu asked McManimon what the difference was between an active layperson and a deacon. He received a simple response: "The grace of the sacrament."

Ministry revival

The 2010 figures released by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) in May show that the ministry has taken a firm hold in the United States; here deacons account for a projected 17,047, or 46 percent, of the worldwide total of 37,203.

Brooklyn Deacon Greg Kandra, who writes about the diaconate on his Beliefnet.com blog "The Deacon's Bench," says that the reestablishment of the permanent diaconate after 1,200-plus years of inactivity was one of the greatest success stories to emerge from the Second Vatican Council.

"It's a vocation that has just exploded," says Kandra. "The day is fast approaching when the most familiar face in a parish could be a married man with children—the deacon."

While references to deacons can be found in early church records, by the 20th century their role had faded from a full-time ministry to a mere transitional step on the path to the priesthood.

Reviving the permanent diaconate, a ministry in which deacons do not later become priests, was a hot topic at the Second Vatican Council.

"The bishops of the council saw [it] as a way of extending the ministry of the bishop in areas of society that the priests couldn't get to," says Deacon William Ditewig, past executive director of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' formerly named Secretariat for the Diaconate. The permanent deacon would be an ordained minister working in the everyday world.

Anna Weaver is a Hawaii-born writer who recently relocated to Washington, D.C. This article appeared in the December 2010 issue of U.S. Catholic (Vol. 75, No. 12, pages 12-17).

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Deacons and priests

As the wife of a deacon, I can tell you that many priests are jealous of the deacons. My husband has had to serve with two different pastors who would not let him preach although he is a professional public speaker. The priest in charge of deacons in our diocese treats the deacons like enemies, always scheduling MANDATORY meetings during the day when most people work and sending emails complaining that people don't show up for ridiculously scheduled ceremonies (7:00 PM on a week night ) without any consideration that it is supposed to be God, family, work and THEN Diaconate. All this in a bad economy when my husband is forced to work many more hours and not counting commuting.

Since the US permenent

Since the US permenent diaconate is exclusively a lay vocation, SEPARATE FROM THE PRIESTLY DIACONATE TRACK AND OPEN TO MARRIED MEN, EVEN CRADLE CATHOLICS, then it should also be open to laywomen as well.
Christ didn't ordain any deacons at all, it was an innovation of the early Church leaders, thus manmade...so this diaconate is not of divine sacramental origin, like Holy Orders!!

But since there were no female deacons in the Medieval Church, whose restoration of its practices, seems to be the stated goal of all the work of the Pope, the Curia and the Hierarchy nowadays, of course there won't be any thought of it at all!!

Diasconate

It I NOT a lay vocation!

Why not women deacons?

That's my comment.

young deacon

While I appreciate the concern for not having young deacons, the numbers in the article portray the problem.
First let me say, I was invited to an informational meeting on becoming a deacon.
Start:
168 hr in week
-68 hr for sleep (8 hr/7)
-40 hr for work
-5 hr for commute to work
== 55 remaining hours left in your week
23 hr of ministry in the parish in which you are assigned
== 22 hr
5 traveling to get there
== 17 hr left in your week
1.5 attend mass on Sunday (they ask for you to attend daily mass, but we will not count that here)
15.5 left in your week
0.5 hr taking care of 'nature calls'
4.5 hr eating at least 4 family evening meals a week
== 10.5 left in your week

That gives you 1.5 hr per day to:
read all the theology books, (our deacon candidates shared they have typical assignments of 400-600 pages of reading/ month - so 100-125/week)
And write their 5-10 page paper with bibliography

and spend 'quality time' with wife, and children.

Matthew Kelly shares that relationships thrive under carefree timelessness. If I took 5 years of my life out of that schedule (and bTW, my work hours are more than 40 as a veterinary doctor), my family would be unknown to me, and I would be unknown to my family.

Part of the problem is that my generation was so poorly catechized, we need a huge education in the basics.

And if I had been in Deacon training, I would not have been able to go to the Theology of the Body talks, and take the training to become certified by the Theology of the Body Institute as a presenter.

Yes, a wonderful gift, but a sacrifice for a family that I was not able to see how it would help my family become the best version of themselves.

discernment

Ray in Il, it sounds like you have all of the reasons not to be a deacon - and that is part of the discernment process. Job, family, and involvement in many activities (your time breakdown of your week shows this) is part of the discernment. Not all are called to this ministry, but those of us who are baptised can fulfill our call in many other ways.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.