Logo

Hold your fire! Let's call a truce in the war on Christmas

Thursday, December 15, 2011
Hold your fire! Let's call a truce in the war on Christmas
ShareThis
  
To the barricades, patriots! Lock down the airports! Suspend the Constitution! Appropriate billions of dollars! Prepare a preemptive attack! The enemies, whoever they are, have launched a war on Christmas!



Here's the intel: This war, evidently, is being fought on two fronts. First, the pious pundits of fair and balanced cable TV news have determined that those nasty, unscrupulous, butt-dumplings of the liberal left have launched an anti-Christian attack on our most sacred holy day. And second, just as we've long suspected, the commercialization of Christmas has reached the tipping point. The regents of retail have tossed off all references to a Christian celebration in favor of generic holiday come-ons. They've taken Christ out of Christmas, and we want him put back!

Careful analysis of the political and commercial activity of this nefarious yuletide axis of evil has determined that they possess a growing arsenal of WCDs, Weapons of Christmas Destruction. And that they intend to use them on us, the unsuspecting coalition of Christian Americans who devoutly kneel, side by side with Santa, at the cradle on December 25.

Without an immediate and forceful response of shock and awe, Christmas will be lost and our Christian nation will sink into the winter darkness of secularism without the manger at the mall, without our blessed tree in the town square, and without "Silent Night" wafting through the halls of our public schools. These are the times that try men's souls. But united we will stand, and in God we will trust. Commence firing!

Wait! Stop! Hold your fire. This all sounds way too familiar. Is there a war on Christmas? Is the intelligence accurate? Are there really WCDs hidden in the political agenda of the liberal left and the retail strategy of commercial enterprise? I don't think so.

This whole war on Christmas business got started a couple of years ago with a book written by Fox News commentator John Gibson: The War on Christmas: How the Liberal Plot to Ban the Sacred Christian Holiday Is Worse Than You Thought (Sentinel). My brother, a brilliant entrepreneur and a Rush Limbaugh-listening, Fox News-watching Reaganista, was kind enough to send me a copy. Thanks, bro.

Now our Lord Jesus told me not to call anybody a fool. (Matthew 5:22. Of course, two chapters later in 7:26, he goes and calls the guy who built his house on sand a fool. Go figure.) So I'm going to play it safe and not call this guy Gibson a fool. But what an idiot!

Gibson spends 190 pages ranting about how the liberals won't let public schools and municipalities celebrate Christmas. He laments that school administrators have banished the word "Christmas" and have inserted "holiday" in its stead. With great umbrage he goes on about how the Christmas tree has been replaced by the holiday tree. He harumphs about how Christmas parades and Christmas parties have been tossed in favor of "holiday" versions of the same thing. He shrieks with righteous indignation because towns won't allow the crèche to be set up on public property or Christmas hymns to be sung in public school celebrations. He reasons that since Christmas is Christian, and since most Americans are Christian, American public institutions should celebrate Christmas.

This guy just doesn't have a clue. Here's the deal: I don't want some public school teacher telling our kids about Christmas. I certainly don't want some TV newsboy dictating the criteria for the Christmas celebration. He equates Christmas with a Scotch pine, for crying out loud.

And the crèche? Don't get me started. If we're going to do the crèche, then I want us to do it. I don't want the crèche retailers setting the scene for the birth of Christ. I've seen a lot of manger scenes, and frankly some of them give me the willies. Somehow the Holy Family in translucent plastic with a light bulb stuck up their insides doesn't celebrate the Incarnation of the living God for me. Last year I got a catalog of Christmas tchotchkes that featured a crèche with all the characters played by dogs. Dogs! The ox was a Lab, the ass was a Doberman, the shepherds were, well, shepherds; the sheep were poodles-even the baby Jesus was a schnauzer.

And I don't want religious hymns sung in public schools for the same reasons. Can I trust Ms. Fundy, the fourth-grade teacher, to explain to her class that the lines "Away in the manger, the poor baby wakes / But little Lord Jesus, no crying he makes" don't accurately reflect the humanity of Christ, who shares in our human suffering? (I would say that little Lord Jesus cried plenty if he shared my humanity.)

This is the same classroom, by the way, that introduces the possibility that God, under which this nation stands indivisible, somehow approves of such American institutions as abortion, the death penalty, and unjust wars of aggression. No thanks.

This is the reason we have a clear separation of church and state written into the Constitution. The government is no more competent teaching theology than I am teaching rocket science. We Catholics have one source of religious learning and that's the magisterium of the church. If it don't come from Rome, you don't take it home. Otherwise you're paying for your kids to get religion from whatever denomination du jour the teacher belongs. What do you suppose "The Church of What's Happening Now" has to say about the pope?

And as far as outrageous commercialization and taking the "X" out of Xmas subverting your kids' Christian understanding of the reason for the season, I've got this to say: that's why God gave them parents-to teach them the difference.

Expanding the seasonal market is a good business strategy in the American free economy. Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, and Baha'i bucks are as good as Christian cash any day. Besides, where would Christmas be without all the commercial hype? Subtract all the shopping frenzy, the incessant barrage of advertising, the sales, the greeting cards, the neighborhood display contests, the catalogs, the presidential tree, and Santa at the mall, and what do you get? Pentecost!

When's the last time you fretted over Pentecost shopping and getting your list of Pentecost gifts crossed off? When did you stay up half the night addressing Pentecost cards and baking Pentecost cookies? Have you ever enthralled your kids with stories of the Pentecost Dove coming down the chimney? No! That's why, no matter how hard we try, Pentecost is just another Sunday.

"Oh, Father, you look good in red." Um, it's Pentecost. "Oh? Well, red is your color. You ought to wear it more often."

And while we're at it, how come no one gets all weirded out about taking Mary out of the Solemnity of Mary, the Mother of God? January 1 comes around and what do we celebrate in our churches? New Year's! I've seen parish bulletins with bubbling champagne glasses, party hats, confetti and horns, and "Happy New Year" banners on the cover. And midnight Masses with the elevation of the host timed to the stroke of 12: What's up with that?

There is no war on Christmas, pilgrims. What we really need is a shopping season for Pentecost.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Christmas is one of the most

Christmas is one of the most loved and celebrated holiday from all christian holidays, and i don't understand why should anyone ever think about starting a war against it. Every religion has the right to celebrate its own holidays, in its own ways, so i don't see the reason why anyone should feel discriminated by other people's beliefs.

assault on Christian holidays

Certainly Christmas is a Christian holiday, no matter what time of the year Jesus Christ was born, which Christmas traditions originated with the "marriage" of pagan and Christian traditions such as the Christmas tree, time of year, etc., or the flagrant commercialism of Christmas. It's based, by Christians, on the birth of Christ and the celebration thereof. That it offends others or that there are faults with the date chosen to celebrate, etc., is not an excuse to openly and viciously destroy the rights to celebrate OPENLY what Christians hold dear to their hearts. It's a joyous occasion for families to gather, exchanging gift which symbolize the greatest gift, his Son, that God gives to us. The disagreement by atheists, Muslims, and so on does not offend me until they attempt to take away my rights to openly enjoy the Christmas season wherever I may be, whether it's on the street, in a city park, in church, or at home. I don't slam a Muslim woman for wearing a burka, an open symbol of her spiritual belief, nor do I slam a priest for wearing his collar in public because I'm not a Catholic. When I get slammed for my open beliefs, trust me...I will fight back.

Where Would We Be...

Where would we be if the early Church went in for the Reverend's de-Christianizing ways? The Church took every good thing in the current culture they could find and baptized it giving it a new Christian identity. Meanwhile, folks like Fr. here want to give it all back for the sake of some convoluted agenda of perfect catechesis and keeping the peace. That's sad.

Jewish perspective on religion in culture

From the perspective of two Jews, Rabbi David Wolpe and Dennis Prager, the removal of religion from cultural life is a tragedy. The whole show is good, but a few minutes starting at minute 22:00 addresses the issue. Gee, it’s not just those wacky conservative Christians who care.

http://dennisprager.townhall.com/TalkRadio/Show.aspx?RadioShowID=3&Conte...

Cultural Identity

Father Paul is a witty writer, but so absorbed by leftist ideology that he can’t see the forest through the trees.

The doctrine of the liberal cult of non-discrimination is that everything is equal. If you think something is better it is because of your in-built bias. If something has succeeded, then it must be for some nefarious reason. If society looks down on something, it must have been the victim of discrimination. Therefore liberals must tear down what is what is perceived as powerful or good and raise up what is perceived as less powerful.

Maintaining a cultural identity is important for survival, so destroying the culture of a America which has institutionalized unjust wars of aggression (in the mind of demented liberals like Father Paul) is a good thing. Columbus Day must be destroyed since Columbus is guilty of genocide since he brought diseases (just as Dr. MLK, and the Dalai Lama would have done if they sailed the Nina, Pinta and Santa Maria.) Thanksgiving must be replaced with a day of mourning for Native Americans. Washington’s Birthday should be replaced with the meaningless Presidents’ Day since he was a slave owner. Mothers Day should not be celebrated in school because it discriminates against a child that has gay fathers for parents. Christmas is not alone as a target for destruction.

Those holidays are to be replaced by holidays emphasizing racial rather than national identity and fighting “injustice” in America. California has Caesar Chavez Day as if his accomplishments were so significant there would be a holiday if he wasn’t Latino. Liberals are pushing Harvey Milk Day to indoctrinate children that Christians oppress homosexuals.

Liberals have been working for years to remove the religious element from Christmas and finally destroy it in the public square. Liberals want the greeting “Merry Christmas” banned from polite discourse reasoning it may somehow offend non-Christians. The word “Christmas” even in front of “tree” is banned since somehow that will offend people. Father Paul is apparently clueless that liberals call and write stores asking for the word Christmas to be banned and likes to pretend non-liberal Christians are just paranoid fools. Christians don’t mind recognition of Hanukkah or Quanza, they just don’t like the word Christmas being treated as an obscene word.

The trend to remove Christmas and replace it with “Holiday” runs counter to the grain of modern target marketing where retailers show they identify with the likes of consumer. Removing Christmas is to appease the liberals who speak up to ban it, not expand sales to Hindus. If Christians shut up like Father Paul recommends, then retailers will assume they will only lose business if the keep the word Christmas. Effectively banning Christmas has monumental cultural significance on national identity. Get a clue Fr. Paul, raising children in a culture friendly to Christianity is easier than the dominant liberal culture that despises Christianity.

Father Paul’s witty discussion of not wanting public school teachers explaining the theology of “Away in the Manger” is ultimately pointless. Under Father Paul’s reasoning it is more offensive for Catholic schools to have children sing “Away in the Manger.” Catholic schools are not teaching the theology of “Away in the Manger” to eight years olds. The purpose of singing songs is for children to develop a cultural identity. Even non-Christian children can learn about the contributions the Christian culture has made in building the good that America is.

Since liberals view Christianity as an unjust patriarchal institution, any positive portrayal of Christmas in schools must be banned. The only things schools should teach about Christianity are religious wars, the Inquisition and how Christians discriminate against gays.

(Father Paul doesn’t mind calling non-liberals idiots). Listen Mr. liberal idiot! The U.S. Constitution does not clearly imbed “separation of church and state.” That is why the nation established Christmas as a national holiday! The separation of church and state to modern liberals is not what Thomas Jefferson wrote in his letter to the Danbury Convention, but the banning of religious life from the public square.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.