The spirit of Vactican II still speaks to the youth of today
The youth of today would be well served to recall Vatican II's message to the youth of the past.
By guest blogger Ken Trainor
World Youth Day, I suspect, attracts, inspires and/or meets the spiritual needs of those young people looking for a highly structured, hierarchical, institutionalized approach to spirituality, which is what the official version of the Catholic Church currently offers.
It does not reach the many young people, Catholic and non-Catholic, who define themselves as “spiritual,” but are suspicious of institutional religion, often with good reason. This generation has frequently been praised for their strong service values. Their hearts are in the right place.
The church of John Paul II and Benedict XVI will not reach these young people, no matter how many worldwide rallies they hold. The church of John XXIII and Vatican II, however, is tailor-made for them. It’s too bad the current Catholic Church has been trying its best to sweep that church under a rug.
October of 2012 is the 50th anniversary of the Second Vatican Council. Learning about what happened there would excite young people who are interested in spirituality but suspicious of institutional religion.
But my guess is that World Youth Day in Madrid this year will not mention John XXIII or Vatican II. One place to start would be to read the “Message to Youth,” the final “closing comment” delivered during the ceremonies ending Vatican II on December 8, 1965. Here’s a sample:
“For four years the Church has been working to rejuvenate her image in order to respond the better to the design of her Founder, the great Living One, the Christ who is eternally young. At the term of this imposing re-examination of life, she now turns to you. It is for you, youth, especially for you that the Church now comes through her Council to enkindle your light, the light which illuminates the future, your future. The Church is anxious that this society that you are going to build up should respect the dignity, the liberty, and the rights of individuals. These individuals are you. The Church is particularly anxious that this society should allow free expansion to her treasure, ever ancient and ever new, namely faith, and that your souls may be able to bask freely in its helpful light. She has confidence that you will find such strength and such joy that you will not be tempted, as were some of your elders, to yield to the seductions of egoistic or hedonistic philosophies or to those of despair and annihilation, and that in the face of atheism, a phenomenon of lassitude and old age, you will know how to affirm your faith in life and in what gives meaning to life, that is to say, the certitude of the existence of a just and good God.
“It is in the name of this God and of His Son, Jesus, that we exhort you to open your hearts to the dimensions of the world, to heed the appeal of your brothers, to place your youthful energies at their service. Fight against egoism. Refuse to give free course to the instincts of violence and hatred which beget wars and all their train of miseries. Be generous, pure, respectful, and sincere, and build in enthusiasm a better world than your elders had.
“The Church looks to you with confidence and with love. Rich with a long past ever living in her, and marching on toward human perfection in time and the ultimate destinies of history and of life, the Church is the real youth of the world.”
The message of Vatican II is the message young people need to hear at World Youth Day.
By Ken Trainor, a practicing, progressive Catholic, who was 10 years old when Vatican II began. For the past 20 years, he has been a reporter, editor and weekly columnist for Wednesday Journal, a newspaper in Oak Park. You can find his column at OakPark.com/Opinion/KenTrainor.
For the week of August 15 - August 19, we'll be featuring reflections from guest bloggers in celebreation of World Youth Day 2011. To submit your reflection, email onlineeditor@uscatholic.org with no more than 500 words. We cannot promise your submission will be published.
Guest blog posts express the views of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the views of U.S. Catholic, its editors, or the Claretians.
Talked to Young Catholics Lately?
By Jonathan F. Sullivan (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011I wonder if Mr. Trainor has actually talked to any young Catholics lately. From reading this piece I don't get the sense that he has.
Young Catholics live in a Vatican II Church. It's what we were raised and formed in; it is all we have known. (I include myself, having been born 13 years after the close of the council.)
That some of us embrace more "traditional" devotional and liturgical practices is not an indication that we have been hoodwinked by some faceless institution or that we want to roll back the calendar to 1960. Rather, we approach these things with a sense of rediscovery and reappropriation in light of the council. In a very real sense today's young Catholic are fulfilling the call of Bl. John XIII to re-imagine and re-articulate the great treasury of our faith in light of the modern world.
That Mr. Trainor whats to keep us mired in 1962 says more about him, I think, than about young Catholics or the wider Church.
reply to Jonathan F Sullivan
By Bad Meets Evil (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011I used to feel and think much in the same way you do.
[Because the Vatican II era is all we've ever known, it is understandable that we would feel this way.]
But when I started to have more information presented to me, I began to see that many of the problems lie not only in abuses or in changes not intended by the Council, but probably also in the official liturgical reforms, and with the actual Council itself.
At one time, though I listened to the voices of traditionalists, I thought they were off the mark... but with time, I've found they're not so crazy after all.
Interesting books to check out on this:
"Work of Human Hands" by Fr. Anthony Cekada
"Tumultuous Times" by Frs. Francisco & Dominic Radecki
"They Have Uncrowned Him" by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre
John XXIII and Vatican II are included in WYD teachings
By Albert Schorsch, III (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011No need to despair about WYD. The YOUCAT, the Youth Catechism of the Catholic Church being unveiled at WYD 2011 contains key quotes from Vatican II, Karl Rahner, and Blessed John XXIII, among many others, including Peter Sellers, the British actor.
Here's one from John XXIII: "To do violence to people's conscience means to harm the seriously, to deal an extremely painful blow to their dignity. In a certain sense it is worse than killing them."
So take heart, the Church did not end in 1965, or 1968 for that matter. We are joined as One, Holy, Roman, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, not just the church of John XXIII or the church of JPII and BXVI. More on YOUCAT at --
http://www.ignatius.com/promotions/youcat/?gclid=COvO7v6e06oCFUJrKgod8hpdMA
In Christ,
Albert Schorsch, III
Chicago, IL
Correcting a typo in the John XXIII quote
By Albert Schorsch, III (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011There was a letter "m" missing from "them" in my transcription of the Blessed John XXIII quote. Here's the corrected version:
"To do violence to people's conscience means to harm them seriously, to deal an extremely painful blow to their dignity. In a certain sense it is worse than killing them."
In Christ,
Albert Schorsch, III
Chicago, IL
What a great quote from Vatican II
By Anonymous (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011Too bad it's so depressing to read today. There is no chance it will be fulfilled. The current leadership of the Church and their "orthodox" fans despise Vatican II and are dedicated to burying it.
Have you read the documents
By Elastico (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011Have you read the documents of VII? They are orthodox. Have you heard of the New Evangelization?
Elastico, V-II documents are elastic
By Joan Krebs Glenview, IL (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011You're right. The documents of V-II are orthodox, but they are also elastic. Above, Albert Schorsch mentions JPII and conscience which could be a riff on a Vatican II document. Vatican II challenged the church to re-imagine ourselves, especially by going to our scriptural roots and become disciples of Jesus once again.
"New evangelization". Of course we've heard of it. One problem is that it isn't an official program yet. The office hasn't yet opened at the Curia. We can only look to signs and symbolic events that cater to our personal/group assumptions as to its official meaning. So why did you bring it up as if it carries an importance in reality? What has this got to do with the question at hand - that of youth and message of Vatican II?
The Vatican II documents are often ambiguous
By Bad Meets Evil (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011The documents of the Council were often written (deliberately so) in such a way that they could appease conservatives at the Council (or be interpreted in an "orthodox" way)... but also so that they could be used by the Modernists to push their unorthodox agenda, and be interpreted in a "Modernist" or "liberal" way.
Sorry, but I can't share the enthusiasm that John Paul II (not to mention the liberal Novus Ordites) had for the Second Vatican Council. I don't see much of a "New Springtime"... I see a sick and diseased Church.
It's easy to label me a "prophet of doom and gloom" as some no doubt will (and as John XXIII labelled those who justly feared the results of Vatican II) ... but I am just a realist and a Catholic who loves Christ, and wants to see the Church be built up, not torn down.
From your lips, or finger
By Anonymous (not verified) on Tuesday, August 16, 2011From your lips, or finger tips, to their ears, or eyes.
'Great thoughts, Ken
By Joan Krebs Glenview, IL (not verified) on Monday, August 15, 2011And thank you for them. At the time of Vatican II I was much older than you I still came within the paradigm of youth that I see used by those in charge of the Madrid WYD. I agree with practically everything you wrote, but I do think also a Vatican II message, like everything else in the 21st century, needs re-framing.
For anyone who cares, and I think that includes you, over the weekend I read that the next WYD will be held in Rio. It won't be next year, the anniversary of Vatican II. Symbolism?
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.

