Father forgive them
Jesus' last words point to injustice but also forgiveness.
Guest blog post by Donna Carroll
“And when they came to the place which is called The Skull, there they crucified him.... And Jesus said, ‘Father forgive them, for they know not what they do.’”
Earlier this month, a courageous young man, weeks short of graduating from Dominican University, sat in a Georgia jail, facing the possibility of being deported. His name is David. He is second generation, undocumented—innocent, but for circumstance. He has lived his entire childhood in the shadows, but he dreams of the sunlight of the Resurrection.
And so, he and seven of his peers courageously stepped out of obscurity. “Undocumented and unafraid.” They put their experience into words—public words, painful words, truth-telling words. “We will not be moved.” Ironically, that day as they sat alone on that Georgia street, stopping traffic, and hoping to stop their friends’ exclusion from higher education, they no longer felt isolated.
And no longer would the rest of us remain in ignorance. Jesus in his enormous compassion said of his persecutors, “they know not what they do.” But the courage of David and his friends, and of all of those who cry out from the margins of our society, does not permit us such luxury. We who gather at the foot of the cross this Lent carry the burden of knowing what we do—of knowing the multitude of injustices that are committed in our name, with our complicity, if not our support.
And yet, the gospel tells us that Jesus’ first word is always, forgiveness.
Even before we sin, we are forgiven. Though we too crucify God’s son, we are forgiven. So now what?
As it turns out, David was not deported; he is safely back on campus, and I look forward to awarding him his diploma on May 7. At Dominican University, David found the embrace of a loving community, loneliness was replaced with conviction, he spoke his truth—and his words live beyond the jail. But he is only one of many waiting in the shadows, seeking the light of justice.
Father, forgive us, and transform our hearts. May we, the forgiven, step into the light as well.
Guest blogger Donna Carroll is the president of Domincan University. She delivered this Lenten meditation at St. James Episcopal Cathedral as part of a program on the Seven Last Words of Christ.
For more on Lent, visit uscatholic.org/lent. Submit a guest blog post about Lent to onlineeditor@uscatholic.org.
Guest blog posts express the views of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the views of U.S. Catholic, its editors, or the Claretians.
Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness' sake..
By Anonymous (not verified) on Wednesday, May 4, 2011While David was breaking a law of the United States, he was also standing up for himself and other undocumented persons in America. God the Father created us in His own image and likeness. To shun one of God's creations based on illegal status is an injustice that we must all seek to end. David is a very powerful young man who took his chances and stood up against the government to voice his opinion. As an undocumented student, resources are not very plentiful. David had refused to stay silent any longer. We must hold people like David in high esteem and work with the government to override unjust laws. In the Vatican II document, Gaudien et Spes, one section emphasizes the importance of respect for the human person. It calls us to look upon our neighbors as another self, holding that other individual's life with high esteem and dignity. It is our goal to become a neighbor to all and to help others who need us. It is important to remember the words of Christ: "As you did it to one of the least of these my brothers or sister, you did it to me." Any injustice we commit against a fellow neighbor, we also commit against the Creator. That is why undocumented students such as David need our help to overcome the hardships of the U.S. immigration system. We need to remember that David is our brother, and that we are all equally loved in the eyes of God the Father.
Catholic Social Teaching
By Elis (not verified) on Tuesday, May 3, 2011As President of Dominican, Donna Carroll stated, "And Jesus said, ‘Father forgive them, for they know not what they do.’” Jesus helped the hungry, the homeless, and the poor. Many illegal immigrants come to the United States in hopes of no longer being the hungry, homeless, and poor in their countries. They come for a better life. Do we as a people of God "know what we are doing?" One of the principles of Catholic Social Teaching teach us that humans have a "Call to Family, Community, and Participation." This principle states, "how we organize our society in economics and politics, in law and policy - directly affects human dignity and the capacity of individuals to grow in community." Everyone should be allowed to grow within the community which they chose to live in. We should not have so many harsh restrictions, especially for people like David. Yes laws must exist, but there should be a way in which people like David can get the chance to live their life to their highest potential. The voice of many young immigrants must be heard, especially since so many of them were brought here by their parents and are here to do good for our country. Another very important CST principle is “Solidarity.” This principle states, “we are one human family whatever our national, racial, ethnic, economic, and ideological differences….the virtue of solidarity is the pursuit of justice and peace.” This is a major issue of both justice and peace for our country. We need to show our fellow brothers and sisters that they are loved and in return peace will prevail. I am proud to be a Dominican student and to be a part of such a loving and caring community.
Caritas et Veritas
By MC (not verified) on Tuesday, May 3, 2011Jesus showed compassion just as each one of us should. Jesus did not shun away from those that needed help. In fact those that did need help never seemed to be just a regular person but perhaps someone ill or less fortunate. We are all born in the image of God and Jesus died for our sins. No one is perfect and by standing up for someone such as David is a courageous act that I feel Jesus would have done. We are all forgiven our sins so that we can learn from those mistakes and make up for them. In doing so we must respect the law and keep a mutual peace among everyone. Those that are ignorant must be educated and it is our right to learn. Life is about learning and is a constant process of that. As David proceeds to go on in life he will make much more of it and look back on what happened as an experience and hardship he overcame. We should not be selfish as to hold back someone who is going in the right direction. As a whole, each one of us should have a change of heart for the better of bringing us closer to each other. Dominican, as a community, has shown that and hopefully our message can be spread just as the word of the Lord. Our generation is both one of change and struggle. We must let the light of truth shine through and allow us all to reach that middle ground where we are all the children of God. Caritas et Veritas.
Glad I am a part of Dominican University
By Olive Yellukapally (not verified) on Tuesday, May 3, 2011Truly, this is a wonderful news. I'm grateful, and amazed that the people can be so good and helping the helpless. I also know many Immigrants who have come to the United States for better life and to support their families back at home. They struggle so much and stay away from their family just so that their families can live a better life, and their children can go to school and grow as better people. One of the guys I know, he worked as a Math teacher in a high School in India, but the school didn't pay him his salary for about 2years, and he want not able to take care of his family. Therefore, he came to the U.S. as a visitor and over stayed here. He stayed away from his wife and 5 kids for about 13 years or more, and he still works hard, walks for about 2 miles to get to his work place. He doesn't care about his struggle but all that he cares about is that his wife and family should live happily. He meets all their needs, and even their wants he wouldn't leave behind. Many of the American citizens offered him to get married and be legalized but he said "I can't be unfaithful to my wife. If I have to live all my life struggling away from my family, I would live. Only because I'm able to give them better life back home." I hope someone would help him and people like him to get legalized as David had been helped. So that he can go and bring his family to the U.S.
And I appreciate "The Catholic Social Teaching!"
A Just God
By Jessica (not verified) on Tuesday, May 3, 2011Despite the warm and welcoming arms of those that attend Dominican University, David and other illegal immgrants like him, have still broken the law. When laws are broken, punishments should be enforced. Therefore, just as God is welcoming and present for all those who call upon him, he also wishes his people to learn from their mistakes and to accept punishment for what they have done wrong.
The current law is not unjust.
By Anonymous (not verified) on Sunday, May 1, 2011“Father forgive them” also applies to those who would substitute personal morality for federal law in a democratic society. We do not live in a dictatorship where we do not have access to the ability to change our national laws. There are many laws that we may feel are not just based upon our own sense of right and wrong. That does not give us the right to decide which laws we will obey and which will not obey. To act in such a manner puts us upon a slippery slope that invalidates the social contract that we all have with one another. Current immigration law is not immoral, and it is not unjust. The injustice committed to “undocumented” students was committed by their parents when they decided to enter our country in violation of federal and international law. They placed their children in this untenable position. If we want to create a path to citizenship for this group of illegal aliens then we need to pursue the democratic process to change our laws. We owe respect to this process to all of our fellow citizens.
David, Donna, Dominican U.
By Kaye Ashe, O.P. (not verified) on Thursday, April 28, 2011David's courageous action and Donna Carroll's reflection on it give witness to DU's mission: "to participate in the creation of a more just and humane world."
Proud to be a Dominican
By Sr. Patty Caraher, OP (not verified) on Thursday, April 28, 2011Donna Carrol's words resonate in the DNA of what it means to be a Dominican, to speak words of truth and justice as we embrace the mercy of God. Thank you, Donna.
Pride
By Tim (not verified) on Wednesday, April 27, 2011I too am a Dominican Student. David is my friend and my brother in both the eyes of God and in the Dominican University family. On May 7th, I will graduate proudly with David. President Carrol, your words are the voice of Dominican and all of us are behind you.
I am a student at Dominican
By Cynthia (not verified) on Tuesday, April 26, 2011I am a student at Dominican University and reading this just puts joy in my heart. President Donna Carroll is full of compassion and so much wisdom. I aspire to be her when I'm older and lead with such a big heart in all that I do.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.

