Bringing the Pakistan flood close to home
Pakistan is suffering, but where is George Clooney? Has anybody else noticed that the attention to the flood in Pakistan has been minimal compared to other disasters?
Every time I've seen a Catholic News Service story on the flood in Pakistan in the past few weeks, I've posted it in hopes that our tiny little site might be raising awareness of the great needs in Pakistan. But I've seen little of the coverage of the flood elsewhere.
After the earthquake in Haiti, we were constantly inundated by charitable appeals and telethons hosted by big stars (not to say that Clooney and his pals should be responsible for drumming up donations). Perhaps it helped that it was the beginning of the year, but Americans showed an outpouring of love for their tiny neighbor.
I have yet to see a commercial telling me to text a $10 donation to the Pakistan flood relief fund, despite hearing that this disaster's impact is bigger than Haiti, the 2004 Tsunami, and 2005 earthquake in Pakistan combined.
Here, at least, is a website that can bring that impact to home--literally. Use this tool to see what the affected area would look like in the United States. Using Chicago, it looks like the area affected is larger than all of the Great Lakes combined.
I imagine that a big reason for the lack of public attention to Pakistan is its relative inaccessibility--perhaps there are fewer journalists there and they are less able to get the story out. Catholic Relief Service, as always, is a good source for reliable information, and a good place to donate money to. (Also it's good to see from that our government is responding to the needs of its ally.)
Perhaps also contributing to the different responses is the fact that while Haiti is closely tied to the U.S. and the area the Tsunami hit includes tourist destinations, few Americans have personal connections to Pakistan. But five years ago this week, we were still struggling to realize the full impact of Hurricane Katrina. That disaster's legacy certainly teaches us to respond generously and swiftly to those in need.
As CRS reports, Pakistan's needs will continue for a long time. Let's not leave the fundraising to George Clooney. We can mobilize an outpouring of generosity through our churches. Perhaps the bishops can call for a national collection for Pakistan as they did for Haiti last winter as well.
I'd just like to say I was
By Anonymous (not verified) on Thursday, October 14, 2010I'd just like to say I was touched reading this article, I felt deeply the kindness you so obviously have within you because despite obvious issues between american christians and pakistani muslims you show a desire to help people in need, which I find truly inspiring. myself not being a religious person, I am inclined to do 'God's work' as it were and lend a helping hand. Thank you for restoring my hope in this world that people get past differences in times of need.
Pakistani Flood
By Jerry D (not verified) on Monday, August 30, 2010Pakistan is complicated, but it his the bomb and a bunch of Islamic radicals in the countryside who want to impose Islam on the world whether or not we give them aid.
I think most people are fine using our military assets to provide immediate lifesaving relief, but propping up a nuclear state is not on the mind of most people. (Granted you may want to prop up the nuclear state to keep the bomb out of the hands of Al Queda, but that doesn't exactly tug on the heartstrings.)
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.

