Logo

Maciel, serial abuser: Let the apologies begin

Monday, April 26, 2010
ShareThis

The publisher of the Legionaries of Christ-backed National Catholic Register, Father Owen Kearns, has finally apologized to the victims of the Legion's founder, Father Marcel Maciel, a pathological liar and abuser who, as Jason Berry has reported for the National Catholic Reporter, bribed his way through the Vatican to gain favors for the Legion and its lay affiliate Regnum Christi. Why it took Kearns so long to apologize to victims is unclear, though Kearns says in the statement he as been ready to do so for some time.

It remains to be seen whether other high-profile defenders of Maciel will issue their own apologies, notably papal biographer and commentator George Weigel and Mary Ann Glendon, the former ambassador to the Holy See. The late Father Richard John Neuhaus is beyond apology, though his journal First Things offers this defense in his case.

The Maciel case is a perfect example of seeing only what one wants to see, and one reason why victims of child sexual abuse are rarely believed. Who could imagine that someone so "holy" could ever be guilty of such crimes?

Maciel's victims, including his own biological children, continue to suffer, and the fact that the Legion of Christ still exists is a scandal. It was created completely in immorality through a web of deception and abuse woven by a man whose behavior can only be described as sociopathic. The order purchased its influence with the kind of bribery that would make the characters of the Godfather blush. And through its many arms, including Regnum Christi and the National Catholic Register, it has sown nothing but discord in the Body of Christ.

There is only one remedy for this corruption, and that is to eliminate it. The Legion of Christ must be suppressed, along with Regnum Christi. Its members must be helped to discern new communities in which to live out their vocations, and the order's billions of dollars in assets and institutions must be investigated and disposed of according to church law.

Furthermore, the shady corruption revealed by Jason Berry must also be investigated and its perpetrators dealt with, both those who offered the money and those who accepted it. Only be shining a light on this or any corruption that has exposed the innocent to danger can the church ever emerge from this tragedy.

Posted in: In preview mode

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Let's not forget

Let's not forget it was JP II who was the biggest supporter of the LOC. Our beloved Pope Benedict has inherrited HIS mess, due to mishandling, subterfuge and outright cronyism. Of course, the modernist-leaning author of this article fails to point this out, since the last pontif embodies his ideals of burlap and guitars for the masses.

So, I guess cronyism runs both ways, doesn't it?

Abuse

I came across this at Post Secret. I think it expresses the anger that many of the abused feel. No suggestion this was by clergy.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_a7jkcMVp5Vg/S9N_LMhbufI/AAAAAAAALmY/SeWBN7wiSx...

No suggestion of forgiveness there

Re: Abuse

No suggestion of forgiveness here either, but there's a reason God didn't call me to be a member of the clergy.

forgiveness

Forgiveness is the key though. Will they surrender their life that God gave them, to emotionally remaining a hostage to their attacker, for ever? BELIEVE me it is not easy to forgive. It is though, a decision of the mind and will that must be renewed each day. Eventually you may FEEL that you can let it go, but without the forgiveness first as an act of the will, not the heart, peace and the ability to move on NEVER can happen. Thus you remain a hostage to your attacker forever. That is my only complaint about the self-rightousness of some of the writers on this subject. Their focus is on "burning down the village" of Maciel or other abusers and pouring salt in the earth, so nothing grows there again, but you cannot help but feel that they are more interested in venting their own rage than helping the victims. If their focus was on the healing of the victims, would they be using them as a battering ram in their own struggles with obedience to their vows or frustrations? Punish the guilty. That will happen here or in eternity, but FREE the victims by helping them with forgiveness.

Rage here is a *good* thing

The ideas of "help the victims to forgive" and "don't vent your rage" are *exactly* why the Church is in this situation. That's how the Church sponsored pedophiles. The victims were supposed to just forgive and "heal" and go away. The abusers were not to be raged at, they were just to be shuttled somewhere else. Don't you get it? Raging against pedophiles is a *good* thing. They can be forgiven while in prison where they can't prey on children.

If the Pope dissolves the

If the Pope dissolves the Legion what will happen to all the students in their schools and all the seminarians. As a high school graduate from one of the schools it would hurt to see a school my parents poured money into not only in tuition but donations be shut down. i believe that the legion just needs to be under new leadership not by a legionary but by an outside group. To shut down schools and this order will affect thousands of people that do not deserve it.

Bryan Cones's picture

Schools and other institutions

I don't think they need to be closed, just transferred to some other group's jurisdiction. It will be a complicated process, which is why this requires a thorough accounting of the billions in assets the Legion holds. It will be a difficult process, but a necessary one.

Bryan Cones

It would never work though

It would never work though you would be taking away in some cases teachers that are priests and consecrated people from the students. Keep the Legion around just get rid of the top leaders who they have replaced as their Father Macial. People like the idea of the Legion i know i do i like its conservative beliefs and such ideals but there is mass amounts of abuse not just sexually but abuse of power. throw out all the higher ups and put it under new management. with it being a order with the billions of dollars that many of the high schools never see you must treat it like a business and just rebuild the top. but to put schools and consecrated under completely new order would never work. i dont care about the priests; i care about the seminarians that are my friends and the students in the schools as well as the consecrated people i may not agree with them giving their whole life to this cause but they are great people and should not be forced to suffer through this.

HOLDING CLERGY AND CHURCH LEADERS ACCOUNTABLE BEFORE THE LAW

HOLDING CLERGY AND CHURCH LEADERS ACCOUNTABLE BEFORE THE LAW

Professor Marci Hamilton and Sister Maureen Paul Turlish on NPR's Radio Times on WHYY in Philadelphia 04/12/2010
http://whyy.org/cms/radiotimes/2010/04/12/holding-clergy-and-church-lead...

Sister Maureen Paul Turlish
Victims' Advocate
New Castle, Delaware
maureenpaulturlish@yahoo.com

a little self promotion ?

Nothing like a little self-aggrandizement to bind the wounds of those hurt by this ehhh sister? Are you an advocate for the young priests in the Legion that might be wounded as well? J.Walter Thompson might do a better job of advertizing your virtues but NPR will provide a more sympathetic ear.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. Links are not allowed and comments with them will be moderated or deleted. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.