Logo

Sex abuse: Benedict succeeds where John Paul failed

Friday, January 22, 2010
ShareThis

An excellent essay in the UK Guardian by Keith Chappell on next month's meeting between the Irish bishops and Pope Benedict XVI regarding the sex abuse crisis in that country points to a big difference between this pope and the last: a far more robust response to child sex abuse.

Many faulted Pope John Paul II, rightly I think, for a slow and insufficiently direct response to the U.S. sex abuse crisis. Part of the fallout has been the decimation of the moral authority of both the U.S. bishops and the Catholic Church as a whole. The Irish church can expect the same.

But Benedict, who met with representatives of the original U.S. lay review board as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, has been more proactive. Already he has accepted the resignations of four bishops--more than in the United States--and none have gotten the shamefully easy treatment that former Boston Archbishop Cardinal Bernard Law now enjoys. B16 also met with victims of sex abuse when he came to the U.S. in April 2008.

Although nothing can undo the damaged suffered by victims, this is a development Catholics of all stripes can celebrate: The Vatican is finally getting it. Perhaps we can hope that the clerical culture of secrecy that abetted these crimes will finally come to an end.

Related links: U.S. Catholic magazine executive editor Meinrad Scherer-Emunds on an Irish bishop's "appalling disregard for the truth."

Posted in: In preview mode

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Sex Scandal....Catholic

I was abused as a child by my father...I was (not) Catholic. In finally becoming Catholic I have been blackballed from the beginning just because I was a victim of sex abuse....not even by a Priest. The church makes it LOOK like they are helping victims I assure everyone they are not. I've had religious openly make fun of me, abused me verbally etc., one Nun dragged me out of a church saying I wasn't welcome...even the most liberal Catholic churches have never reached out to me. I've lost friends, everything just because I decided one day to improve my life just a tiny bit and become "religious"....I've lost all belief in other people and how cruel they can be to someone who was tortured as a child.....All I wanted was friendship and a chance of a better life!

I can relate (well, a little bit anyway)....

With each day that passes, I really feel like most "church people," and most people in general, are not very nice, don't REALLY care to help those in need, and really are selfish, closed-minded, and rotten deep down.... but then I suppose I'm being judgmental, which is not good. 

My own personal remedy (and I mean this seriously!!!):  Turn on an Eminem CD, and turn it up.  It really helps with looking at and dealing with one's own feelings of anger and disappointment.  I think this is why his music was/is so popular.

In any event, you're in my prayers and I hope things will work out better for you.

Megan Sweas's picture

JPII

I'm curious of what you all think about this story: "Pope John Paul practiced self-mortification, postulator confirms." http://uscatholic.org/news/2010/01/pope-john-paul-practiced-self-mortifi...

I don't know what to think about it.

John Paul the Great

I agree that JP wasn't perfect as we judge him today. But he didn't choose to be pope when the abuse scandal broke. Nothing like that had ever happened. But that does not discount the many years of leadership and massive amount of writing he gave us.

The praise for Benedict is that he learned from JP-whether directly or just by watching, I don't know- how to handle this situation.

JPII was not the greatest

JPII was not the greatest pope (take a look at his progressive episcopal appointments in America for example), but he was indeed a saintly man. He's a saint.

John Paul ii response to US sex abuse

Perhaps Pope John Paul's poor response to the clerical sex abuse is reason why he should not be on a fasttrack to sainthood.

JP II, Sex Abuse and Sainthood

I don't know enough to have an opinion on JP II's sainthood, but the sex abuse crisis may or may not impact his sainthood.

If he did not address the American sex abuse crisis adequetely because he didn't care about the victims, that is one thing. It is also possible his management skills were to up to task to recognize the gravity and handle the crisis.

If the reason is the latter, it is not a reason to withhold sainthood unless the measure of sainthood is perfection in all things.

25 Years of "Pooh, Pooh" From John Paul Two

Sorry, but JPII sat on that sex scandal for twenty five years! When he was forced to face it, he invited "poor" Cardinal Law to run to the Vatican to get away from (paraphrasing his attitude) "mean Americans and their filty kids who seduced poor, innocent priests."

I am NOT immpressed by JPII, at all! At best he was a dolt. At worst, he was a creep!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.