Logo

Blaming God for our failure in Haiti

Thursday, January 14, 2010
ShareThis

It's too bad every bit of religious idiocy that comes out of Pat Robertson's mouth gets a headline, his Haiti remarks being an egregious case in point. And it's worse that every Christian with access to a media outlet doesn't immediately grab the mike and denounce what he says and at least offer another Christian response to it, however unsatisfactory, and there are no easy answers to the suffering of the innocent.

Having faith doesn't mean that God is going to protect us. It only means that we have hope, and that when things like this happen, when poor, oppressed, forgotten people are ground down under yet another heel--even a natural disaster--we see the image of God ground down, we see Jesus crucified again, we see our very selves and our own children crushed.

Catholics sometimes call it solidarity, and it's a hell of a lot more than writing a check. It means recognizing our own hand in the suffering of the poor--and not just blaming God for "allowing" it to happen. It means asking how the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere can be just a few hundred miles from the richest country that has ever existed. Or how 2 billion people live on a dollar or two a day or lack access to clean water or secure food when it is well within our power to provide those basics. If God is mad about anything, I'd look there.

We've allowed Haiti to happen, just as we allowed Katrina to happen, just as we allow poor people all over the world to be left basically defenseless against the onslaught of nature and globalization and environmental destruction. God is just our excuse for doing next to nothing about it.

Posted in: In preview mode

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

god loves us so much just

god loves us so much just ask haiti LOL!

Who knows, maybe God was

Who knows, maybe God was punishing them. The Bible seems to support the idea that he has done this before.

Haiti

Blame God? Let's blame ourselves --- all who profess faith in Jesus. For how long have we been hearing (not necessarily listening) to His Word? For how long must we keep the RC Church's Social Teaching hidden on our bookshelves?

Before the earthquake, we listened to God's Word & the Church while at the same time we knew of the poverty in Haiti and didn't do anything about it -- despite what God has told and taught us. How many people died because we did not help them build better, stronger houses?

I just hope and pray that christians of all denominations and people of all faiths reflect upon what has happened in Haiti and ask ourselves: why did we let this happen?

Glad to hear YOU know God's will!

How dare any of you seriously debate God's will?
Do you think that the strongest and wealthiest country in existence is God's will or that Haiti suffer is God's will? The question itself is unanswerable. To what end do you hope to acheive by even debating it? (other than showing your narrow mindedness)

The earthquake did not cause the suffering, the lack of suitable manmade infrastrcture did. It is not the lack of giving money to the poor that has kept it underdeveloped. It is the lack of the the haitians tapping into their human potential to prepare.

It's your fault.

It's your fault.

Isn't it.........................

Isn't it 'de rigor' to blame Bush for the earthquake in Haiti? I mean, that's the liberal standard, isn't it?

Haiti's tragic situation has

Haiti's tragic situation has to be solved
by the whole world, especially by the U.S.

This is not the time to find fault with God,
fault with the people of Haiti, or the corporations. It was very painful to see that
Haiti was the poorest nation in the western
hemisphere. It was ruled by ruthless royalties,
then plunged into disorder and chaos. Finally,
the worst event took place.

Now, a massive rebuilding has to take place, and
that may be the beginning of a new chapter in
the history of Haiti. Let us all pray and
work hard to help them to wipe their tears and
to give a new life the living.

Bryan I agree with you.

Bryan I agree with you. Haiti is poor because it has been abused and exploited. Corporations thrive by using their cheap labor, and when their democratically elected government wants to raise the minimum wage a little, a coup takes place. It's rice farmers went bankrupt when tariffs were lifted, and the market was flooded with heavily subsidizes American rice. This is one way free trade it's happening everywhere. All our governments worship at the altar of the corporations. It's not corporations but their insatiable appetite for profit. Enough is never enough. Nothing could stop the earthquake, but sound infrastructure would minimize the deaths and damage.

Corporate Greed in Haiti?

Please name the corporations that are using cheap labor in Haiti.

It may be emotionally satisfying to blame corporations, but we need to look at reality and step up to the plate and dig from our own pockets.

The reality is Haiti is a hell hole created by the people of Haiti. Corporations are not invensting in Haiti because it is so chaotic. Cruise lines that provided tourist income no longer stop in Haiti due to the violence.

Progress comes usually as a result of a few great men. Those of us who have not been brainwahed by the Howard Zinn version of history have deep gratitude to the founders of the United States for setting up such a great society. We have gratitude for those who have fought and died for our freedom.

Sadly, instead of being founded by great men, Haiti has been run by a bunch of despots. Since the vast majority of people of Haiti were born in horrific circumstances and do not have the means to get out of it, we try to help as much as we can within the limitations that it is an independent country run by corrupt officials.

[ i deleted comment ]

[ i deleted comment ]

 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.