Logo

Selling out your Sister

Thursday, May 14, 2009
ShareThis

There has been no small amount of glee over the Vatican investigation of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious and the general "quality of life" survey of U.S. religious women, best summarized by a blogger for the UK Times, who headlined his post, "Great news: Vatican to investigate America's bossy feminist nuns," the content of which is complete drivel.

But most egregrious is the Conference of Major Superiors of Women Religious' press releases accompanying the investigation, in which the CMSWR basically throws the LCWR under a bus: "The religious communities of the CMSWR have maintained the historical form of religious life, with sisters living in community and wearing the habit. While many religious orders are currently facing marked decline in novitiates and the aging of their members, the communities of the CMSWR are experiencing growth on a worldwide scale."

In other words "liberal" nuns are to blame for the decline in religious life (despite the fact that all forms of vowed life have shown similar declines). The CMSWR is revealing what it really wants, which is to have LCWR stripped of its Vatican recognition, leaving CMSWR as the sole recognized organization of U.S. religious women.

I've got a column coming out on this, but I can summarize here: I'll take a "bossy, feminist nun" any day. I've learned more from them about being a Catholic and a human being than from anyone else. The Vatican and CMSWR may think they deserve an investigation; I think they deserve a medal. 

Posted in: In preview mode

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

You can't have your cake and eat it to!

There are some religious orders who belong to both of these Conferences. I don't think members of either of these Conferences have the time to worry about what each other is doing. They are busy living their vows!

There is a notable trend in young women being attracted to what is considered a more 'traditional' community lifestyle. My question is, if a traditional life style works for members of the CMSWR, then why do other people knock it. They are living their lives through their religious vows in service to the Church. That's what religious life is, not what you think it should be or want it to be!

What some individuals from the LCWR got caught up in was a 'cultural revolution' in the sixties and that's where they are stuck!

Bryan Cones's picture

Who's knocking whom?

That's the thing. I don't think anyone is "knocking" those who want a "traditional" monastic lifestyle. I certainly am not: One of my writers is a Trappist nun who lives a very "traditional" monastic lifestyle. It's the traditionalists that are, in my view, "knocking" the apostolic types that are exploring new ways of being religious.

Bryan Cones

The Church according to Bryan

Greetings,

Well before I look into the statistics that you did not cite, all nuns are sisters but not all sisters are nuns. Nuns are cloistered. In addition, you are publicly questioning the legitimacy of the Vatican’s right to visit the congregations it alone sanctions—the Church according to Bryan.

Timothy+

1. Ebaugh, Helen Rose (1998), "Orders", in Swatos, William H., Encyclopedia of Religion and Society, Rowman Altamira, pp. 341

I agree with Bryan. Saw an

I agree with Bryan. Saw an interesting email/letter on the subject by Sandra M. Schneiders, I.H.M. at NCR - We've given birth to a new form of religious life

Bryan Cones's picture

Schneiders

Thanks for the link, Crystal. Schneiders is always on target. 

Bryan Cones

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
U.S. Catholic insists on a civil and respectful dialogue on our website, following our Comment policy. Comments should be charitable, on topic, and brief. U.S. Catholic reserves the right to delete comments deemed inappropriate. We encourage you to choose your words wisely.